The Weakest Link: How Strengthening Assessment Leads to Better Federal Hiring

cover thumbnail Author(s): Partnership and PDRI
Publication Date: 08/26/2010
Publication Topics: Recruiting and Hiring, Strategic Human Capital Planning
Publication Type: Research Reports and Surveys
Download ACROBAT 532k Download


For our government to succeed and achieve its mission, it must be able to identify and hire skilled, capable and dedicated employees.

Everyone agrees that the federal government doesn't always hire well, with talent lost because the selection process today moves too slowly and because hiring managers and human resources personnel often do a poor job of selecting the right candidates--those who will be the most successful in the job.

The Obama administration is seeking to address these issues with a hiring reform plan that calls for agencies to "select high-quality candidates efficiently and quickly."

Given the direct connection between good hiring decisions, a first-class civil service and a high performing government, the Partnership for Public Service, in cooperation with PDRI, a PreVisor Company, took an in depth look at how agencies are assessing candidates for federal jobs today, the barriers to hiring the best candidates and how the process can be improved.

Our study found that applicant assessment is the weakest link in the government's problematic hiring chain, with top candidates frequently getting lost in meaningless evaluation. The public is the biggest loser, because the result often is a wasted opportunity to strengthen the civil service.

Start a new search »

The Partnership for Public Service is a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that works to revitalize our federal government by inspiring a new generation to serve and by transforming the way government works.


2013 Best Places to Work in the Federal Government® Analysis: Staff/Manager Alignment
In our new Best Places to Work in the Federal Government® analysis, the Partnership for Public Service and Deloitte examined the issue of disparities between managers and employees.
Download ACROBAT 93k Download
Building the Enterprise: A New Civil Service Framework
In the report, the Partnership for Public Service calls for major reforms to the federal government’s decades-old civil service system and lays out a plan to modernize areas that include the outdated pay and hiring policies.
Download ACROBAT 307k Download
Management Matters: Creating a 21st Century Government – Part II, Outside Views
Partnership President and CEO Max Stier’s testimony before the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs about the management challenges facing our federal government.
Download ACROBAT 242k Download
Helping Government Deliver: Transforming Mission and Support Services
In the new report, “Helping Government Deliver: Transforming Mission and Support Services,” the Partnership for Public Service and Deloitte identified four organizations who are developing transformative, enterprise-wide approaches to shared service delivery.
Download ACROBAT 910k Download
Ten Years of BPTW Rankings: How Six Federal Agencies Improved Employee Satisfaction and Commitment
The Partnership for Public Service and Deloitte examined the past decade of Best Places to Work rankings to profile six high-performing agencies. Learn from their experiences and get tips to increase employee satisfaction and commitment at your agency.
Download ACROBAT 429k Download
From Data to Decisions III: Lessons from Early Analytics Programs
The Partnership for Public Service and the IBM Center for the Business of Government set out to learn how agency leaders and program managers can get past the hype about big data to reap mission value from analytics.
Download ACROBAT 667k Download
Taking Measure: Moving from Process to Practice in Performance Management
How has performance management been impacted by the Government Performance and Results Modernization Act of 2010? Where have advances been made and what challenges remain? That’s what the Partnership for Public Service and Grant Thornton set out to understand in the new report, “Taking Measure: Moving from Process to Practice in Performance Management.”
Download ACROBAT 418k Download