Leadership out of balance: Vacant top posts, record political appointees and a shrinking career corps

The Trump administration continues to politicize and destabilize the leadership of federal agencies. Nearly 100 of the most senior posts in Cabinet departments sit vacant. Beneath them, the president has installed more political appointees who never faced Senate confirmation than any administration in at least 40 years. And the career executives who have long kept agencies running across administrations are at their lowest numbers in at least a quarter century.

These are trends we have documented in our report on the politicization of federal leadership, a three-part series on agency-level trends and analyses of Senate-confirmed turnover and non-Senate-confirmed appointee departures. Each trend has only deepened.

Our updated analysis found that:

  • Nearly a third of Senate-confirmed positions in Cabinet departments are vacant, and most have no nominee, leaving more agencies run by acting officials who never faced Senate scrutiny.
  • Nearly 3,000 non-Senate confirmed political appointees now serve in Schedule C positions in confidential or policy-determining roles or as non-career members of the Senior Executive Service, the government’s top management tier. That is more than 450 above any administration since at least President Ronald Reagan.
  • The career Senior Executive Service has shrunk by nearly 30% since the end of 2024, and political appointees now hold a record share of SES positions, leaving fewer experienced leaders to keep agencies running as appointees come and go.

Together, this trifecta of trends leaves agencies with fewer experienced career leaders, fewer senior officials scrutinized by the Senate and more appointees vetted only by the president’s team and chosen largely for their loyalty to the White House, not for their expertise, management experience or leadership capabilities. That combination leaves agencies less equipped to deliver on their missions and meet public needs, exposes their operations to more disruption as appointees cycle in and out, discourages long term planning and shifts power further toward the president with fewer checks from the Senate.

Senate-confirmed vacancies

Many of the most senior leadership positions in the federal government are vacant. Senate-confirmed officials have left at record rates, and the president has made historically few nominations, both to replace those who departed and to fill positions that have been vacant since the start of the administration. He has also withdrawn a record number of the nominations he has made. The result is a growing number of top posts with no confirmed leader and no nominee on the way.

As of Nov. 12, 97 of 301 (32.2%) Senate-confirmed positions across the 15 Cabinet departments were vacant. Only 29 had a nominee pending, seven of them nominated since Nov. 9. The Department of the Treasury had the most vacancies, with 11, followed by the departments of Health and Human Services and Justice, with 10 each. Four departments had no nominee for any of their vacancies.

The Senate is likely to confirm many of the 29 pending nominees before the end of the year. But the remaining vacancies will persist and the overall number is expected to grow, with Democrats taking control of the Senate in January and turnover typically peaking in an administration’s third year. More departures and fewer confirmations point to more of the government’s top posts being filled by acting or interim officials in 2027.

Record levels of non-Senate-confirmed appointees

As nominations have slowed, the president has leaned more heavily on political appointments that do not require Senate confirmation. He has continued to place these appointees at a record pace and created Schedule G, a new category of political appointments established by executive order in July 2025, to add more. The result is the largest political workforce in at least 40 years, and it is still growing.

Schedule C political appointments have hit new records. As of Sept. 30, 2,150 Schedule C appointees were serving, more than 350 above the peak of any previous administration since 1985 (prior record of 1,783 under President George H.W. Bush in 1991). The count first passed that record at the end of 2025 and has grown steadily through this year.

Non-career SES appointees have also hit a record. They now number 842, more than 60 above the previous high of 778 under President Bill Clinton. They passed that record in February and have kept climbing.

The growth is sharpest in a set of major agencies. In agencies that have long had non-Senate-confirmed appointees, the numbers have surged to as much as five times their historical levels. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has 27 non-Senate-confirmed appointees, double its 2009-2024 average. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the Employment and Training Administration and the Food and Drug Administration each have four to five times their historical averages.

In agencies long led by career officials below the Senate-confirmed level, appointees have arrived at levels with no modern precedent. The Drug Enforcement Administration, the IRS and the Forest Service had no non-Senate-confirmed appointees from 2009 to 2024 and now have 11, six and four. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the National Institutes of Health and the Veterans Health Administration, which averaged two or fewer, now have 10 or more.

Five of the agencies with record levels of political appointees also have no Senate-confirmed head: ICE, the Employment and Training Administration, the FDA, the Veterans Health Administration and the IRS. Three are run by non-career SES appointees who never faced Senate confirmation: David Venturella at ICE, Kyle Diamantas at the FDA and John Figueroa at the VHA.

Relying on non-Senate-confirmed appointees this heavily has its limits. These appointees tend to turn over quickly, and under this administration they are leaving in greater numbers than under any recent president at the same point. Of the 1,877 who had left their positions as of June 15, nearly half lasted six months or less, and nearly a quarter left within three months.

That churn has a cost. Appointees who leave that quickly rarely learn how their agencies work, build relationships with the staff who carry out their decisions or stay long enough to answer for the results. Each departure restarts the cycle of selection, onboarding and lost momentum.

Career leadership at a record low

Career executives have historically provided the continuity that short-tenured appointees cannot. Their ranks are now the smallest in at least a quarter century.

The career SES has lost nearly 30% of its members since the end of 2024, falling from 8,127 to 5,745 as of Sept. 30. That is the smallest career SES since at least 1998 and more than 400 below the previous low. Most of the losses came in 2025. Since January, the number has held near its low point with no sign of rebuilding.

As political appointees have grown and career executives have shrunk, the balance of the SES has shifted. Political appointees now hold 12.8% of filled SES positions, up from 8.5% at the end of 2024. Before this administration, that share had not exceeded 10% since at least 1998. By law, non-career appointees can make up no more than 10% of all SES positions. But that cap is calculated against allocated positions, including vacant ones, rather than the positions actually filled. As career vacancies go unfilled, the political share of executives serving can keep rising without surpassing the statutory limit.

Restoring the balance

The second Trump administration has shifted the leadership of federal agencies away from Senate-confirmed and career officials and toward political appointees the Senate never vetted. Top posts sit empty or in the hands of acting officials. Below them, a record number of appointees, selected and vetted only by the White House, fill the ranks. And the career executives who have long provided continuity are fewer than at any point in at least a quarter century.

These trends leave agencies less able to fulfill the mandates Congress gives them to meet public needs and to take on the long-term work, strategic planning and challenges that outlast any single appointee’s tenure. At the same time, each vacancy filled by an acting official and each appointee placed without Senate review shifts more power to the president and undercuts the Senate’s constitutional role in approving the government’s top leaders. Congress should act now to:

  • Reform the Vacancies Act to reexamine the discretion it gives presidents to fill vacant Senate-confirmed posts and to ensure the Senate keeps its critical role in deciding who leads them.
  • Strengthen transparency on who is leading agencies. The Vacancies Act already requires agencies to report acting officials to Congress and the Government Accountability Office, but those requirements often go unmet. Congress should oversee compliance and consider new reporting mechanisms or penalties for failing to report, along with more frequent public reporting on who holds non-Senate-confirmed positions.
  • Cap the number of non-Senate-confirmed appointments so the size of the political workforce is not left entirely to presidential discretion.
  • Conduct oversight, examining the loss of experienced career leaders and how it is affecting agencies’ ability to deliver on their missions.

We will continue tracking these trends through our Government for a New Era initiative, which is developing reforms that balance political responsiveness with effective government management. Our new brief, Reimagining political leadership, lays out a vision for that work: appointees selected for their competence and character, placed in roles that call for political direction, kept to the numbers effective leadership requires and held accountable for results. The trends documented here show how far the current system has drifted from that vision.

Author: Chris Piper

Chris Piper is a senior manager of policy who leads the Partnership’s political leadership and executive branch oversight work.